Karnataka High Court2025W.P(C) No.18216/2017
Of course. As a Senior GST Legal Analyst, here is a structured summary of the judgment.
***
### **Judgment Summary: Esds Software Solution Limited vs Assistant Commissioner Of Commercial**
**Date of Judgment:** 22 April, 2025
**Court:** High Court of Karnataka at...
Orissa High Court2025WP(C) No.20229
Of course. As a Senior GST Legal Analyst, here is a structured summary of the judgment in *Heramba Narayan Panda vs The Commissioner Cgst & Cx*.
***
### **Summary of Judgment: Heramba Narayan Panda vs The Commissioner Cgst & Cx**
#### **1. Outcome**
The High Court disposed...
Karnataka High Court2025WRIT PETITION NO. 108748
Of course. As a Senior GST Legal Analyst, here is a structured summary of the judgment in *Karibasappa Durgappa Hadagali vs The Additional Commissioner*.
***
### **Judgment Summary**
**1. Outcome**
The Writ Petition was allowed in part. The High Court quashed the...
The precedent established that mistakes like...
Applying the principle of judicial consistency, the...
Consequently, the Court quashed the impugned orders...
Patna High Court2025No.470 of 2024
Of course. As a Senior GST Legal Analyst, here is a structured summary of the judgment in M/S Bathla Telectech Pvt. Ltd vs The State Of Bihar.
***
### **Judgment Summary**
**Case Title:** M/S Bathla Telectech Pvt. Ltd vs The State Of Bihar & Others (Lead case: M/s Utkrisht...
**Non-Application of Mind by Authorities:** The...
**Distinguishing Precedents:** The Court agreed...
Patna High Court2025No.470 of 2024
Of course. As a Senior GST Legal Analyst, here is a structured summary of the judgment in *M/S Bathla Teletech Pvt Ltd vs The State Of Bihar*.
***
### **Judgment Summary**
**Case:** M/S Bathla Teletech Pvt Ltd vs The State Of Bihar (Lead Case: M/s Utkrisht Trade Solutions...
It emphasized the **Explanation to Section 16(2)(b)...
The Court noted that the GST law marks a departure...
The authorities below failed to apply their minds...
Patna High Court2025No.470 of 2024
Of course. As a Senior GST Legal Analyst, here is a structured summary of the judgment in M/S Bathla Teletech Pvt. Ltd vs The State Of Bihar.
This judgment addresses a group of similar writ petitions, with CWJC No. 17914 of 2023 (M/s Utkrisht Trade Solutions Pvt. Ltd.)...
It clarified that the Explanation to Section...
The Court observed that physical possession is not...
The authorities failed to apply their minds to the...
Patna High Court2025No.470 of 2024
Of course. Here is a summary of the judgment as requested.
***
### **Judgment Summary: M/S Bathla Teletech Pvt. Ltd vs The State Of Bihar**
**Date of Judgment:** 11 April, 2025
**Bench:** Hon’ble Mr. Justice P. B. Bajanthri, Hon’ble Mr. Justice Alok Kumar Sinha
**Lead...
The **Explanation to Section 16(2)(b)** is clear...
The Court found that the tax authorities had erred...
While upholding the assessee's interpretation, the...
Patna High Court2025No.470 of 2024
Of course. As a Senior GST Legal Analyst, here is a structured summary of the judgment.
***
### **Judgment Summary: M/s Utkrisht Trade Solutions Pvt. Ltd. vs. The State of Bihar & Others (Lead Case)**
*Note: The court heard a batch of petitions, with the facts and...
**Deemed Receipt is Statutorily Recognized:** The...
**Departure from Previous Tax Regimes:** The Court...
**Burden of Proof:** While the dealer is deemed to...
Allahabad High Court2025No. 1082 of 2022
Here is a summary of the judgment:
---
**1. Outcome**
The writ petition filed by M/S Dee Control And Electric Private Ltd is **allowed**. The impugned order dated 27.02.2024 (passed in appeal), the original order dated 05.04.2019, and the notice dated 15.12.2018, all...
Furthermore, referencing *M/s Maa Mahamaya Alloys...
It clarified that liability to pay tax under...
For Section 130(1)(iv) to apply, there must be a...
Allahabad High Court2025No. 1278 of 2024
As a Senior GST Legal Analyst, here is a summary of the judgment:
**1. Outcome**
The writ petition was allowed. The impugned order dated 09.01.2020 passed by the Deputy Commissioner and the appellate order dated 31.05.2022 passed by the Additional Commissioner were...
Regarding Section 130(1)(iv), the Court found it...
**Valuation by eye estimation:** While not the...
Allahabad High Court2025No. 1082 of 2022
Here is a summary of the judgment from the perspective of a Senior GST Legal Analyst:
---
**1. Outcome**
The writ petition was allowed. The impugned orders dated 16.05.2024 (appellate) and 26.09.2022 (original) were quashed. The Court directed that any amount deposited by...
***M/s Shree Om Steels Vs. Additional Commissioner...
Section 35(6) of the CGST Act empowers the proper...
Therefore, even if unaccounted goods are "deemed to...
Allahabad High Court2025No. 1278 of 2024
Here's a summary of the judgment:
**1. Outcome**
The writ petition was allowed. The impugned orders dated 31.05.2022 (passed by Additional Commissioner) and 20.07.2021 (passed by Deputy Commissioner) were quashed, as they could not be sustained in the eyes of law.
**2. Core...
Specifically addressed Section 130(1)(ii) and (iv),...
Section 130(1)(ii) is inapplicable because the...
Section 130(1)(iv) requires the establishment of an...
Karnataka High Court2025WRIT PETITION NO. 27259
**1. Outcome**
The High Court allowed the petitions, setting aside the impugned orders passed by Respondent No.3 (Assistant Commissioner of Central Taxes). It held that the taxpayer's refund applications/claims were **not barred by limitation**. The matters were remitted back...
Section 54 of the CGST Act is **directory and not...
When tax is levied without the authority of law...
The Court concluded that the impugned orders, which...
Karnataka High Court2025WRIT PETITION NO. 27259
Here is a summary of the judgment:
**1. Outcome**
The petitions are allowed. The impugned orders passed by the Assistant Commissioner of Central Taxes (Respondent No.3) rejecting the refund claims are set aside. The High Court held that the refund applications/claims of the...
**Constitutional Mandate & Unjust Enrichment:**...
**CBIC Circular on "Subsequently Held":**...
**Admission of Facts:** The Court noted that the...
Karnataka High Court2025WRIT PETITION NO. 27259
**M/S Merek Life Science Private Limited vs The Union Of India on 7 November, 2025**
**1. Outcome**
The Karnataka High Court allowed the petitions, set aside the impugned orders rejecting the refund claims on grounds of limitation, held that the refund claims were not barred...
Section 54 of the CGST Act and Rule 89(1A) are...
Where tax is collected without authority of law...
The department has a duty to assist taxpayers in...
Karnataka High Court2025WRIT PETITION NO. 27259
**Judgment Summary: M/S Merek Life Science Private Limited vs The Union Of India**
---
**1. Outcome**
The High Court of Karnataka allowed the writ petitions. It set aside the impugned refund rejection orders passed by Respondent No. 3 and held that the petitioner's refund...
The Court highlighted Article 265 of the...
Applying principles of restitution and unjust...
The Court also noted that CBIC Circular No....
Karnataka High Court2025WRIT PETITION NO. 27259
Here is a summary of the judgment:
**1. Outcome**
The High Court allowed the writ petitions, set aside the impugned orders rejecting the refund applications, and held that the refund claims were not barred by limitation. The matters were remitted back to the Assistant...
Citing *Comsol Energy Private Limited v. State of...
The Court found that the Central GST authorities...
The Court also noted that CBIC Circular No....
Patna High Court2025No.470 of 2024
Of course. As a Senior GST Legal Analyst, here is a structured summary of the judgment in *M/S Sane Retails Private Limited vs The State Of Bihar*.
***
### **Judgment Summary: M/S Sane Retails Private Limited & Ors. vs The State Of Bihar**
---
#### **1. Outcome**
The...
The CGST Act represents a departure from older tax...
The Court distinguished the precedents relied upon...
The Court concluded that the lower authorities had...
Patna High Court2025No.470 of 2024
As a Senior GST Legal Analyst, here is a structured summary of the judgment in *M/S Shreyash Retail Private Limited vs The State Of Bihar*.
### **1. Outcome**
The writ petitions were **allowed**. The impugned orders passed by the Adjudicating Authority (Deputy Commissioner...
Patna High Court2025No.470 of 2024
Of course. As a Senior GST Legal Analyst, here is a structured summary of the judgment.
***
### Judgment Summary: M/S Shreyash Retail Private Limited vs The State Of Bihar
**Case Reference:** The judgment adjudicates a batch of petitions, with the lead case being **CWJC...
The Court reasoned that the Explanation clearly...
This provision in the CGST Act marks a departure...
The Court found that the authorities below had...
Patna High Court2025No.470 of 2024
Of course. Here is a structured summary of the judgment as requested.
***
### **GST Judgment Summary: M/S Utkrisht Trade Solution Pvt. Ltd vs The State Of Bihar**
**1. Outcome**
The writ petitions were allowed. The impugned orders passed by the Adjudicating Authority...
The Court gave significant weight to the...
The Court observed that the GST regime is a...
The lower authorities had failed to apply their...
Patna High Court2025No.470 of 2024
Of course. As a Senior GST Legal Analyst, here is a structured summary of the judgment in M/S Utkrisht Trade Solutions Pvt. Ltd vs The State Of Bihar.
***
### **Judgment Summary: M/S Utkrisht Trade Solutions Pvt. Ltd vs The State Of Bihar**
**Date of Judgment:** 11 April,...
It clarified that the CGST Act does **not** mandate...
The lower authorities committed an error by failing...
The Court distinguished the precedents relied upon...
Madras High Court2025No.6524 of 2022
Here is a summary of the judgment:
---
**1. Outcome**
The Madras High Court allowed the Writ Petitions (W.P.Nos.6524, 6527 and 6537 of 2022) filed by M/s. Gillette Diversified Operations Private Limited, setting aside the impugned orders rejecting their refund claims....
Gujarat High Court2025NO. 26250 of 2022
Of course. As a Senior GST Legal Analyst, here is a structured summary of the judgment in *Patson Papers Private Limited vs Union Of India*.
***
### **Judgment Summary: Patson Papers Private Limited vs Union Of India**
**Date of Order:** 28 March, 2025
**Court:** High Court...
Karnataka High Court2025WRIT PETITION NO. 10699
Of course. As a Senior GST Legal Analyst, here is a structured summary of the judgment.
***
### **Judgment Summary: Propcare Mall Management (India) Pvt Ltd vs The Deputy Commissioner of Commercial Taxes**
**1. Outcome**
The writ petition was disposed of in favour of the...
Gujarat High Court2025NO. 18892 of 2023
Of course. As a Senior GST Legal Analyst, here is a structured summary of the judgment in *Shah Paperplast Industries Ltd vs Union Of India*.
***
### **Judgment Summary: Shah Paperplast Industries Ltd vs Union Of India**
#### **1. Outcome**
The petitions were allowed in...
Karnataka High Court2025WRIT PETITION NO. 16609
Of course. As a Senior GST Legal Analyst, here is a structured summary of the judgment in *Shri. Mahalinga Patali vs The Commissioner Of Central Excise*.
***
### **Judgment Summary**
**Case Title:** Shri. Mahalinga Patali vs The Commissioner Of Central Excise &...
Madras High Court2025No.27621 of 2021
**1. Outcome**
The Writ Petitions were allowed. The impugned common orders dated 27.04.2021, which rejected the refund claims, were set aside. The case was remitted back to the Assistant Commissioner for a fresh order, directing them to allow the refund claims along with...
**Revenue (Joint Commissioner of GST and Central...
SEZ units benefit from a special scheme with...
Supplies to SEZ are "Zero-rated" for the...
Jharkhand High Court2025No. 5267 of 2023
Of course. As a Senior GST Legal Analyst, here is a structured summary of the judgment in *Vinod Udaipuri vs Union Of India*.
***
### **Judgment Summary: Vinod Udaipuri vs Union Of India**
**W.P. (T) No. 5267 of 2023 | High Court of Jharkhand at Ranchi | Date:...
Patna High Court2024No.4583 of 2024
Excellent. As a Senior GST Legal Analyst, here is a structured summary of the judgment in *Ambay Traders vs Union Of India*.
***
### **Judgment Summary: Ambay Traders vs Union Of India**
**Date of Judgment:** 18 March 2024
**Court:** High Court of Judicature at...
Karnataka High Court2024WRIT PETITION NO. 3997
Of course. As a Senior GST Legal Analyst, here is a structured summary of the judgment in *Deeta Constructions Pvt Ltd vs The Union Of India*.
***
### **Judgment Summary**
**Case Title:** Deeta Constructions Pvt Ltd vs The Union Of India & Ors.
**Citation:** WP No. 3997 of...
Karnataka High Court2024WRIT PETITION NO. 13616
Of course. As a Senior GST Legal Analyst, here is a structured summary of the judgment in *Imtac India Pvt. Ltd vs Assistant Commissioner Of*.
***
### **Judgment Summary: Imtac India Pvt. Ltd vs Assistant Commissioner Of**
**1. Outcome**
The writ petition was disposed of...
Bombay High Court2024WRIT PETITION NO. 2980
Here is a summary of the judgment:
1. **Outcome**
* The Court rejected the petitioner's challenge to the constitutional validity and legality of **Sections 7, 12, 13**, and **16(2)(b)** of the Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017 (CGST Act) and Maharashtra Goods...
Section 7, defining "supply" to include "agreed to...
Sections 12 and 13, by making the date of receipt...
Therefore, the constitutional challenge to Sections...
Karnataka High Court2024WRIT PETITION NO. 8321
Of course. As a Senior GST Legal Analyst, here is a structured summary of the judgment in M/S Body Vigyan vs Assistant Commissioner.
***
### **Judgment Summary: M/S Body Vigyan vs Assistant Commissioner**
**Date of Judgment:** September 3, 2024
**Court:** High Court of...
Delhi District Court2024no. 781113535332
Of course. As a Senior GST Legal Analyst, here is a structured summary of the judgment in *M/S Greenolution Pvt Ltd vs Rhino Concretes India Pvt Ltd*.
***
### **Judgment Summary**
**1. Outcome**
The suit was decreed in favor of the Plaintiff (M/s Greenolution Pvt Ltd). The...
**Deemed Admission of Documents:** Consequently,...
**Significance of ITC Admission:** The court...
**Interest Rate Modification:** While upholding the...
Gujarat High Court2024NO. 16436 of 2023
Of course. As a Senior GST Legal Analyst, here is a structured summary of the judgment in M/S Hilti Manufacturing India Private Limited vs. Union of India.
***
### **Judgment Summary**
**Case Title:** M/S Hilti Manufacturing India Private Limited vs. Union Of India &...
**Restoration of First Debit:** To correct this...
Karnataka High Court2024WRIT PETITION NO.14414
Here's a summary of the judgment M/S Indian Oil Corporation Ltd vs The Assistant Commissioner Of Central ... on 20 August, 2024, structured as requested:
---
### Judgment Summary: M/S Indian Oil Corporation Ltd vs The Assistant Commissioner Of Central ...
**1....
**Interpretation of Section 54(3)(ii):** The Court...
**Consistency with other High Courts:** The...
Allahabad High Court2024No. 1082 of 2022
Here's a summary of the judgment:
---
**1. Outcome**
The writ petition is allowed. The impugned order dated 30.11.2023 passed by the first appellate authority and the original order dated 7.3.2020 passed by the respondent no. 2 are quashed.
**2. Core Issue**
The core issue...
The Court concluded that the law is clear:...
Patna High Court2024No.18027 of 2021
Of course. Here is a summary of the judgment in the requested structured format.
***
### **Summary of Judgment: M/S M Intergraph Systems Pvt. Ltd vs The Union Of India**
**1. Outcome**
The writ petition was **dismissed**. However, the High Court granted liberty to the...
Karnataka High Court2024WRIT PETITION NO.105344
Of course. As a Senior GST Legal Analyst, here is a structured summary of the judgment in *M/S Metgud Tiles vs The State Of Karnataka*.
***
### **Summary of Judgment: M/S Metgud Tiles vs The State Of Karnataka**
#### **1. Outcome**
The writ petition filed by the taxpayer...
Allahabad High Court2024No. 1082 of 2022
Here is a summary of the judgment:
---
**1. Outcome**
The writ petition is allowed. The impugned order dated 16.04.2024 passed by the first appellate authority and the impugned order dated 08.10.2018 passed by respondent no. 2 are hereby quashed.
**2. Core Issue**
The core...
The Court extensively relied on its previous...
Citing `Metenere Limited`, the Court highlighted...
The Court further observed from `M/s Maa Mahamaya...
Karnataka High Court2024WRIT PETITION NO.202670
Of course. As a Senior GST Legal Analyst, here is a structured summary of the judgment in M/S Sampat Traders vs The Union Of India And Anr.
***
### **Legal Summary & Analysis**
**Case Title:** M/S Sampat Traders vs The Union Of India And Anr
**Date of Judgment:** 16...
Andhra Pradesh High Court - Amravati2024No.15351 of 2023
**1. Outcome**
The Writ Petitions were allowed. The orders in original and appellate orders rejecting the petitioner's refund applications were set aside. The 2nd Respondent (Deputy Commissioner of Central Tax) was directed to reconsider the refund applications, allowing the...
Allahabad High Court2024No. 1007 of 2022
Here's a summary of the judgment in the requested structured format:
---
### M/S Shree Om Steels vs Additional Commissioner Grade-2 And ... on 19 July, 2024
**1. Outcome**
The writ petitions were **allowed**. The impugned orders, including the original order dated...
Karnataka High Court2024WRIT PETITION NO. 24003
Of course. As a Senior GST Legal Analyst, here is a structured summary of the judgment in *M/S Sujai Electricals vs The Assistant Commissioner Of*.
***
### **Judgment Summary: M/S Sujai Electricals vs The Assistant Commissioner**
**High Court of Karnataka | Writ Petition...
. **Legislative Amendment:** The Court adopted the...
Karnataka High Court2024WRIT PETITION NO. 21211
Of course. As a Senior GST Legal Analyst, here is a structured summary of the judgment in *M/S Thacher Parambath Abdul Rawoof vs Commercial Tax Officer*.
***
### **Judgment Summary**
**1. Outcome**
The writ petition was disposed of in favour of the petitioner. The High...
Allahabad High Court2024No. 1082 of 2022
Here is a summary of the judgment:
**1. Outcome**
The High Court allowed the writ petition, thereby quashing the impugned order dated 03.04.2024 passed by the first appellate authority and the order dated 24.01.2023 passed by the respondent no. 2.
**2. Core Issue**
The core...
Referencing *Metenere Limited*, the Court...
The Court further clarified, drawing from *M/s Maa...
Section 130(1)(ii) is inapplicable when goods are...
Allahabad High Court2024No. 204 of 2021
**1. Outcome**
The writ petition is allowed. The impugned order dated 26.12.2023, passed by the respondent no. 1 in Appeal No. 204 of 2021 under Section 130 read with Section 122 of the UP GST Act, is hereby quashed.
**2. Core Issue**
The core issue is whether proceedings...
**Referencing *Metenere Limited (supra):*** This...
**Referencing *M/s Maa Mahamaya Alloys Pvt. Ltd....
Tax and penalty cannot be assessed or determined...
Andhra Pradesh High Court - Amravati2024No.15351 of 2023
Here is a summary of the judgment M/S. Seil Energy India Limited vs The Union Of India, on 31 July, 2024:
---
**1. Outcome**
The Writ Petitions were **allowed**. The orders in appeal and original orders rejecting the refund applications were set aside. The 2nd Respondent...
Madras High Court2024No.10770 of 2021
Of course. As a Senior GST Legal Analyst, here is a structured summary of the judgment in *M/S. Wipro Ltd vs The Assistant Commissioner*.
***
### **Judgment Summary**
**Case Title:** M/S.Wipro Ltd vs The Assistant Commissioner, Office of the Assistant Commissioner of GST &...
Kerala High Court2024WP(C) No.24563/2024
Of course. As a Senior GST Legal Analyst, here is a structured summary of the interim order in the case of *Omega Pipes Private Limited vs State Tax Officer*.
***
### **GST Judgment Summary**
**Case Title:** Omega Pipes Private Limited vs State Tax Officer &...
Allahabad High Court2024No. 1082 of 2022
As a Senior GST Legal Analyst, here is a summary of the judgment:
---
**1. Outcome**
The writ petition was allowed. The Allahabad High Court quashed the impugned order dated 11.05.2022, passed under Section 130 read with Section 122 of the UPGST Act, and the appellate order...
Allahabad High Court2024No. 1007 of 2022
Here's a summary of the judgment:
---
### S/S Dinesh Kumar Pradeep Kumar vs Additional Commissioner Grade 2 And ... on 25 July, 2024
**1. Outcome**
The writ petition was allowed. The impugned order dated 24.03.2022, passed by the Additional Commissioner Grade 2 in GST...
**Metenere Limited (supra):** This judgment...
**M/s Maa Mahamaya Alloys Pvt. Ltd. (supra):** This...
Based on these established precedents, the Court...
Allahabad High Court2024No. 1082 of 2022
As a Senior GST Legal Analyst, here is a summary of the judgment:
---
**1. Outcome**
The writ petition was allowed. The High Court quashed the impugned order dated 18.07.2019, passed by the respondent no. 5 under Section 130 read with Section 122 of the UPGST Act, as well...
Andhra Pradesh High Court - Amravati2024No.15351 of 2023
Here's a summary of the judgment:
**1. Outcome**
The Writ Petitions are **allowed**. The orders in appeal and the orders in original rejecting the petitioner's refund applications are set aside. The 2nd respondent (Deputy Commissioner of Central Tax) is directed to...
Andhra Pradesh High Court - Amravati2024No.15351 of 2023
Here is a summary of the judgment:
**1. Outcome**
The Writ Petitions are allowed. The impugned orders in appeal and the orders in original, which rejected the petitioner's refund applications, are set aside. The 2nd respondent (Deputy Commissioner of Central Tax) is directed...
Andhra Pradesh High Court - Amravati2024No.15351 of 2023
Here is a summary of the judgment, structured as requested:
---
**1. Outcome**
The Writ Petitions are **allowed**. The orders in appeal and the original rejection orders are set aside. The 2nd respondent (Deputy Commissioner of Central Tax) is directed to reconsider the...
Andhra Pradesh High Court - Amravati2024No.15351 of 2023
Here's a summary of the judgment:
---
### 1. Outcome
The Writ Petitions are **allowed**. The orders in appeal and the orders in original, which rejected the refund applications, are set aside. The 2nd respondent (Deputy Commissioner of Central Tax) is directed to...
**Subsequent Rejection:** After the amendment and...
**Invoicing Practice:** As per the Power Purchase...
Andhra Pradesh High Court - Amravati2024No.15351 of 2023
**1. Outcome**
The Writ Petitions are **allowed**. The orders in original and the appellate orders rejecting the petitioner's refund applications are set aside. The 2nd respondent (Deputy Commissioner of Central Tax) is directed to reconsider the refund applications, allowing...
Andhra Pradesh High Court - Amravati2024No.15351 of 2023
Here's a summary of the judgment:
---
**1. Outcome**
The Writ Petitions were **allowed**. The Court set aside the original and appellate rejection orders and directed the 2nd respondent to reconsider the petitioner's refund applications. The Court explicitly permitted the...
Andhra Pradesh High Court - Amravati2024No.15351 of 2023
Here's a summary of the judgment in the requested format:
### 1. Outcome
The High Court allowed the writ petitions, setting aside the original and appellate orders of rejection. It directed the 2nd respondent (Deputy Commissioner of Central Tax) to reconsider the...
**Current Rejection:** Following the amendment, the...
**Invoice Practice:** As per the power purchase...
Kerala High Court2024WP(C) No.24525/2024
Of course. As a Senior GST Legal Analyst, here is a structured summary of the interim order in *Shaimon Joseph vs State Of Kerala*.
***
### **Summary of Interim Order: WP(C) No. 24525 of 2024**
**1. Outcome**
The Kerala High Court granted a **temporary interim stay for...
Patna High Court - Orders2024No.4809 of 2024
Of course. As a Senior GST Legal Analyst, here is a structured summary of the judgment in *Shashi Ranjan Kumar vs State Of Bihar*.
***
### **Judgment Summary**
**1. Outcome**
The writ petition was disposed of. The Court granted the petitioner the liberty to avail the...
Andhra Pradesh High Court - Amravati2024No.15351 of 2023
Here is the summary of the judgment:
**1. Outcome**
The Andhra Pradesh High Court allowed the writ petitions, setting aside the rejection orders (original and appellate). It directed the 2nd respondent to reconsider the petitioner's refund applications, permitting the...
Karnataka High Court2024WRIT PETITION NO. 21701
Of course. As a Senior GST Legal Analyst, here is a structured summary of the judgment in *Suvastu Projects Private Limited vs The Commercial Tax Officer*.
***
### **Judgment Summary**
**Case:** Suvastu Projects Private Limited vs The Commercial Tax Officer
**Court:** High...
Madras High Court2024No. 21737 of 2024
Of course. As a Senior GST Legal Analyst, here is a structured summary of the judgment in *Tvl. Aanjaneya Pharmacy vs The Commissioner Of Commercial Taxes*.
***
### **Judgment Summary**
**1. Outcome**
The writ petitions were disposed of. The impugned assessment orders...
The Court also deemed it fair to provide the...
Balancing the interests of both parties, the Court...
Bombay High Court2024Writ Petition (C) No.6793
Here's a summary of the judgment:
---
### 1. Outcome
The Bombay High Court allowed the petition:
* Declared the impugned Circular dated 18 July 2019 as not applicable to the petitioner’s refund applications/claim.
* Quashed and set aside the impugned orders dated 11...
Delhi High Court2023No. 13/2017
Here is a summary of the judgment:
---
**1. Outcome**
The High Court allowed the petition, setting aside the impugned order dated 11.07.2023. The Adjudicating Authority was directed to process the petitioner's application for interest, in accordance with the Court's...
Bangalore District Court2023No.73 of 2007
Of course. As a Senior GST Legal Analyst, here is a structured summary of the judgment in *M/s. Winsid Coatings India Pvt., Ltd., vs Mr. Ganesh Shet*.
---
### **Summary of Judgment**
**1. Outcome**
The Accused, Mr. Ganesh Shet, was convicted of the offence punishable under...
**On Deficient Stamp Duty:** The Court referred to...
**On the GST Input Tax Credit (ITC) Argument:**...
The Accused argued that the Complainant had claimed...
Delhi High Court2023W.P.(C) No.10222/2023
**1. Outcome**
The petition filed by Indian Oil Corporation Limited (IOCL) was **allowed**. The Delhi High Court directed the concerned authority to process IOCL's refund applications for accumulated Input Tax Credit (ITC) along with applicable interest within six...
Punjab-Haryana High Court2023No. 16266 of 2018
Here's a summary of the judgment:
---
**1. Outcome**
The High Court of Punjab & Haryana dismissed the writ petition filed by M/s Bright Road Logistics. It upheld the order of the First Appellate Authority, which had affirmed the Proper Officer's order imposing Integrated...
Since the tax and penalty demanded under Section...
The Court emphasized that "intention to evade...
The Court also confirmed that the petitioner was...
Rajasthan High Court - Jaipur2023Writ Petition No. 8476/2021
Here's a summary of the judgment:
**1. Outcome**
The High Court allowed the writ petitions, setting aside the orders passed by the Adjudicating Authority and the Appellate Authority. The Adjudicating Authority was directed to undertake a fresh consideration of the refund...
**Adherence to Legislative Intent:** Relying...
**Rejection of Revenue's Grounds:**
The court found the revenue's argument of "more or...
Rajasthan High Court - Jaipur2023Writ Petition No. 8476/2021
Here is a summary of the judgment:
1. **Outcome**
The Writ Petitions are **allowed**. The impugned orders passed by the Adjudicating Authority and the Appellate Authority, which rejected the petitioner's refund claims, are **set aside**. The Adjudicating Authority is...
Rajasthan High Court - Jaipur2023Writ Petition No. 8476/2021
Here's a summary of the judgment:
**1. Outcome**
The High Court allowed the writ petitions, setting aside the orders of the Adjudicating Authority and the Appellate Authority that rejected the petitioner's refund claims. The Adjudicating Authority has been directed to...
**Purpose of Section 54(3):** The court reiterated,...
**Applicability of Circulars:** The court noted...
**Computation Method:** The court affirmed that if...
Rajasthan High Court - Jaipur2023Writ Petition No. 8476/2021
**1. Outcome**
The High Court allowed the writ petitions, setting aside the impugned orders of the Adjudicating Authority and the Appellate Authority. The matter was remanded to the Adjudicating Authority for fresh consideration of the refund claims in light of the Court's...
**Legislative Intent (as per VKC Footsteps):** The...
**Applicability of Circulars:** The Court...
**Conclusion on Inversion:** The Court concluded...
Rajasthan High Court - Jaipur2023Writ Petition No. 8476/2021
**1. Outcome**
The High Court allowed the writ petitions, setting aside the impugned orders passed by the Adjudicating Authority and the Appellate Authority. The Adjudicating Authority was directed to undertake a fresh consideration of the refund claims in light of the High...
**Circulars:** The court acknowledged that...
**Computation of Refund:** The court clarified that...
**Conclusion:** The court concluded that the...
Rajasthan High Court - Jaipur2023Writ Petition No. 8476/2021
Here is a summary of the judgment:
**1. Outcome**
The High Court allowed the writ petitions, setting aside the impugned orders of the Adjudicating Authority and the Appellate Authority. The Adjudicating Authority was directed to undertake a fresh exercise of considering the...
Rajasthan High Court - Jaipur2023Writ Petition No. 8476/2021
As a Senior GST Legal Analyst, here is a summary of the judgment:
---
**1. Outcome**
The High Court allowed the writ petitions, setting aside the impugned orders of the Adjudicating Authority and the Appellate Authority. The Adjudicating Authority was directed to undertake...
Karnataka High Court2023WRIT PETITION NO. 5569
Here is a summary of the judgment M/S Premier Sales Promotion Pvt Limited vs The Union Of India on 16 January, 2023:
---
1. **Outcome**
The Writ Petition filed by M/S Premier Sales Promotion Pvt Limited was **allowed**. The orders passed by the Karnataka Authority for...
**Petitioner's Business:** M/S Premier Sales...
**Voucher Usage:** Clients then issue these...
**Nature of Vouchers:** The vouchers in question...
Karnataka High Court2023WRIT PETITION NO. 13185
As a Senior GST Legal Analyst, here is a summary of the judgment:
**1. Outcome**
The Karnataka High Court allowed the writ petition.
* It declared the words "or the value which is 1.5 times the value of like goods domestically supplied by the same or, similarly placed...
**Violation of Article 14 (Equality and Arbitrariness):**
**Hostile Discrimination:** The Court found the...
**Arbitrariness and Unreasonableness:** The rule is...
Karnataka High Court2023WRIT PETITION No.16175
Of course. As a Senior GST Legal Analyst, here is a structured summary of the judgment in M/S Wipro Limited India vs The Assistant Commissioner of Central Tax.
***
### **Summary of Judgment: M/S Wipro Limited India vs The Assistant Commissioner Of Central Tax**
#### **1....
**Justice-Oriented Approach:** Although the...
**Conclusion:** Given the nature of the error and...
Madras High Court2023No.5130 of 2022
Here is a summary of the judgment:
**1. Outcome**
The Madras High Court partly allowed the writ petition, quashing the impugned order of the Tamil Nadu State Appellate Authority for Advance Ruling (TNSAAAR) dated 22.06.2021 (read with 30.03.2021) to the extent it was...
**AAAR Rectification (22.06.2021):** Rectified a...
**RBI Master Directions:** The court noted that...
Madras High Court2023No.5130 of 2022
As a Senior GST Legal Analyst, here's a summary of the judgment:
---
**1. Outcome**
The Madras High Court partly allowed the writ petition. It quashed the impugned order of the Tamil Nadu State Appellate Authority for Advance Ruling (TNSAAAR) to the extent that it...
**Interpretation of Time of Supply (Section 12(4) GST):**
The Court clarified that Section 12(4)...
**Section 12(4)(a):** If the "Gift Voucher/Card" is...
Allahabad High Court2022No.419 of 2022
Here's a summary of the judgment:
---
**1. Outcome**
The High Court allowed both writ petitions, directing the respondents to pay interest to the petitioner on the delayed refund amount of Rs. 4,70,400/- (and Rs. 5,60,000/- in the connected petition) for the period from...
**Arbitrary Withholding:** The Court found the...
**Relevant Date for Interest:** Applying...
**No One Can Benefit from Own Wrong:** Citing...
Bombay High Court2022NO.54 OF 2016
Of course. As a Senior GST Legal Analyst, here is a structured summary of the judgment in *M/S Angerlehner Structural And Civil ... vs Municipal Corporation Of Greater ...*.
***
### **Judgment Summary**
**1. Outcome**
The Court directed the Municipal Corporation of Greater...
Madras High Court2022No.949 of 2022
Of course. As a Senior GST Legal Analyst, here is a structured summary of the judgment in M/S. Atc Tires Private Limited vs Joint Commissioner Of Gst.
***
### **Judgment Summary: M/S. Atc Tires Private Limited vs Joint Commissioner Of Gst**
**1. Outcome**
The Writ Petition...
**Purpose of Zero-Rating:** The very purpose of...
**Correct Interpretation of Rule 89(1) Proviso:**...
**Absence of Double Benefit:** The supplier of the...
Madras High Court2022No.949 of 2022
Of course. As a Senior GST Legal Analyst, here is a structured summary of the judgment in *M/S. Atc Tires Private Limited vs Joint Commissioner Of Gst & on 8 March, 2022*.
***
### **1. Outcome**
The Writ Petition was **allowed**. The High Court quashed the Order-in-Appeal...
The Court reasoned that the entire GST chain must...
If the petitioner (the actual exporter) is also...
The Court interpreted the second proviso to Rule...
Madras High Court2022W.P.(MD)No.20468
Of course. As a Senior GST Legal Analyst, here is a structured summary of the judgment in *Numinous Impex (I) Pvt. Ltd vs The Commissioner Of Customs*.
***
### **Judgment Summary: Numinous Impex (I) Pvt. Ltd vs The Commissioner Of Customs**
**1. Outcome**
The Writ Petition...
**Systemic Issue Not a Legal Bar:** The Court...
Gauhati High Court2021WP(C)No.3878/2021
Here is a summary of the judgment:
---
**1. Outcome**
The Guwahati High Court set aside both the order of the Assistant Commissioner (rejecting the refund claim) and the order of the Joint Commissioner (Appeals) (allowing the refund claim). The matter was remanded back to...
**Partial Exemption:** The Court determined that...
**Flaws in Lower Orders:**
The Assistant Commissioner's order was...
Allahabad High Court2021No.304 of 2020
As a Senior GST Legal Analyst, here is a structured summary of the judgment in *M/S North End Food Marketing Pvt. Ltd. vs State Of U P And 4 Others*.
***
### **1. Outcome**
The writ petition was **allowed**. The impugned order dated 26.03.2021, passed by the Commissioner...
. **Non-Reasoned Order:** The impugned order did...
. **Drastic Nature of Rule 86A:** The Court...
Supreme Court of India2021No 4810 of 2021
As a Senior GST Legal Analyst, here is a summary of the Supreme Court judgment in *Union of India vs Vkc Footsteps India Pvt. Ltd.*:
---
**1. Outcome**
The Supreme Court allowed the appeals filed by the Union of India, setting aside the judgment of the Gujarat High Court...
The Madras High Court took a contrary view, holding...
The Supreme Court heard appeals against both High...
Crucially, the Court noted the legislative...
Gujarat High Court2020NO. 15473 of 2019
Of course. As a Senior GST Legal Analyst, here is a structured summary of the judgment in M/S Britannia Industries Limited vs Union Of India.
***
### **Judgment Summary: M/S Britannia Industries Limited vs Union Of India**
#### **1. Outcome**
The writ petition was...
The Court concluded that since no specific supplier...
Allahabad High Court2020Writ Petition(Tax) No. 334
As a Senior GST Legal Analyst, here is a summary of the judgment M/S Metenere Ltd. vs Union Of India And Another:
---
**1. Outcome**
The High Court partly allowed the writ petition, setting aside the confiscation of goods and the imposition of a penalty exceeding Rs....
Delhi High Court2020No.14/2018
Of course. As a Senior GST Legal Analyst, here is a structured summary of the provided court order.
***
### **Summary of Order: Medical Burea vs Commissioner of Central Goods And Services Tax**
**Court:** High Court of Delhi
**Date of Order:** 03 July, 2020
---
#### **1....
Kerala High Court2020W.P.(C)No.1141/2020
Here's a summary of the judgment:
---
**1. Outcome**
The High Court ordered the immediate release of the detained goods and vehicle to Umiya Enterprise upon the execution of a simple bond, without insisting on a bank guarantee for the demanded tax and penalty amount. The...
Gujarat High Court2018NO. 18962 of 2018
Of course. As a Senior GST Legal Analyst, here is a structured summary of the judgment.
***
### **Summary of Order: Aap And Co. vs Union Of India**
**Date of Order:** 07 December, 2018
**Court:** High Court of Gujarat
**Type of Order:** Interim Oral Order (Issuing...
Madras High Court1800No.8596 of 2019
Here is a summary of the judgment from the perspective of a Senior GST Legal Analyst:
**1. Outcome**
The Madras High Court dismissed all writ petitions challenging:
* The constitutional validity of Section 54(3)(ii) of the Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017 (CGST...
. **Meaning of "inputs":** The Court affirmed that...
. **Validity of Rule 89(5):** The Court concluded...
. **Nature of Refund and Article 14:** The Court...